Mutiny in Baker Street

Huh, why is it that quiet at the moment? Usually, this time is the time where here is the most action and everybody can't read all the postings because it's that much.

Because of Florentina - I would not plank her. How many times did we have it, that a person got that many votings and then they were planked at they were a sailor. So I would observe her tomorrow, but I don't think that it is clever, when there is now a last minute panic and then we plank her.
 
+looks at the clock+
+consults her secret notes+
+raises her eyebrows disapprovingly at seven different people+

Yes. YOU.

[Eo]
 
Ok tough choice for the plank tonight, I got some small things which were eye-catching for me but I am not sure if they are enough to back up a plank already.

I think that I am going to decide between 2 people although I also want to have an eye on the theory from Kicker, as the discussion between Ewry and Mailin was indeed already somehow interessting.

But I will not plank Ewry today cause as Kicker missed out, she indeed had Natti first under her options for the election and not like he stated under the dangerous people. But I will keep an eye on her, specially with that Natti/Ewry connection and the Mailin discussion so her role could be interessting.

My "candidates" for the plank are atm Galdra, as I found her captains vote for herself alittle wierd, considering that she is usually unsure about her own decissions and seems alittle unsure and confused in my view.

Second I found Lexi alittle wierd, as her descission for Mailin and Margaret was pretty fast and without any reasoning. Personally I do not really see the big difference in Mailin Margaret and for example Nam, so its kinda suprising that she was not even considering that. Sounded alittle like "Wanna make a 1-1 vote fast" Lexi also got only one vote for her, which seems wierd to me, considering that a medium skilled experienced player (Flo) was the choice of the majority.

Then we got Margaret, but her comment alone is not reason enough for the plank for sure, considering that her english is not the best so I am not sure if I even understood her right. I still found the comment wierd as it sounded like a mixed pair tried to get ride of the cupid fast, which seems unlikely from my point of view and I still find it irritating that she already thinks that far.
 
And congratulations Mailin^^

As for the plank, there's one person right now that I'm not too happy with. This person is MP.

The thing that's been bugging me is his post where he "defends" Margaret:
While I agree with you that it's way too early to discuss the couple, I sense a misinterpretation of Margarets post.

She surely won't refer to herself as a part of the couple, this would be plain stupid. So that won't be an option to analyze her comment. I rather treat her reaction as a random comment, just to say anything to the night action without judging the couple.
On one side I don't want to defend her, on the other side I fear her statement could be an argument of the category "better than nothing" for later when we need to plank someone and/or people could jump on the train... high interest in the couple and special roles in the early game had been sanctioned badly in the past, even when one is innocent... I speak of experience :p

I hope you get my idea %)

That's one tiny thing I found out, no idea how to interpret it since it could also be totally worthless.

My elections will now go out for Lexi (captain) and me (chief mate).

I don't know, somehow there's a lot of words just to say "Margaret might be a sailor made victim for the plank because of that little sentence, so be careful. Oh, and by the way, I've got no idea what she wanted to tell us". It seems to me like he wanted people to think about Margaret more closely. Whether it would be to make them more likely to remember this particular detail about her or to make sure that people don't consider her for their plank, I've got no idea (I'd think the first one to be more likely), but I get a pretty bad feeling here.

By the way MP, is there a reason why you chose Lexi over your 4 other candidates? I don't find anything.
 
Congratulations Mailin!

So I will plank one of these two:

M.P: rules out Seme, because she has no time, but never counted her in later. Why?

In the player's list are

Kicker, Seme, natt i nord, MP, dieLexi, Margaret, Mizuki, Naemi, ewry, Mailin, Florentina, Galdranorn

and there I already sorted out the players who are too confusing or not available (Seme will get off this list once she states that she's sure to be active on duel day).

In addition to that, there is really no explanations why she voted for Lexi.

dieLexi:
I think its al little bit fishy, that she decided her vote so quikly. I mean, of course Margaret and Mailin are great players, but why not Nam or Seme? I think they are as good as Margaret and Mailin.
 
It sounds somehow like an excuse, after Am wrote above that it was mean and she wanted to play. Ok, it is just one phrase, but I somehow don't like it. The first plank, yes. But this choice of Flo as a captain doesn't somehow make it better, so I stay here.

Somehow I don't like the idea of planking one for writing a post that would be totally normal in any German mutiny. And then there's the early interst for the couple, plus you voted for Florentina. 3 arguments which may not be really convincing but that's the best I have.

My vote will go out for Margaret.

Mailin schrieb:
Twelve, you can't really count Am, can you?

Whoops, my fault :schäm:
 
Of course they were both exactly. :ohoh: My opinion or my argument hadn´t surely changed. And it´s still a difference. I know that you can be/are confusing and I know that Galdra was confusing.

I never wrote that I dont want to choose an experienced player. I wrote that I don´t want to choose somebody who is too dangerous. Just because somebody is not very dangerous it doesn´t mean that he or she is not experienced. I don´t understand your problem. %)

First: Nope. You said, that it could be, that Galdra isn't confusing anymore. And you wrote, that I am sometimes confusing (not exactly these words, but it's the sense of it). But you just don't know if Galdra will be this time confusing or if I'll be confusing this round. So at the end, it is the same.

Second: But you wrote, that some people find her dangerous and some don't. And when I am sure, that I really don't want to choose a dangerous player, then I really wouldn't choose somebody, where at least half of the people are saying, that she is dangerous. I'd choose somebody where I can be sure, that she really isn't dangerous.
 
Started after Lexi's post 18.57

I think I'm going to plan someone of the electors of Flo. And nope, it won't be myself :D
The chance that some mutineers took the chance and followed that idea is very hight with six electors (and me, but I know I'm not a mutineer). So, let's see...

Margaret, Galdranorn, Florentina, Mailin, ewry, Kicker were the electors. Well, I think I'll ignore Florentina here at first, voting for him/herself isn't really suspicios. Of course she could be a mutineer too, but I think it's too risky to put the newly chosen captain onto the plank just because there were too many votes for her.

Kicker is really fast in thinking ewry is suspicious. I don't like that, but I think that's one of Kicker's main problems as sailor - he is too fast in thinking :D So I'm not sure whether I'll plank him.

With ewry... Hmm. Kicker has a point actually, but I think ewry is just a bit confused herself. I saw her being a mutineer and she really does such things as a there. No, I don't think she's going to be my plank.

Mailin is our newly chosen officer and I simply don't know what to think of her. Same counts for Margaret, except she's not officer :D

So there's Galdra left. I didn't see much of her yet, but what I saw was okay.

So well... I think I'll plank Kicker though. I don't like his 'Yay, I will plank ewry!', because I personally wouldn't suspect ewry because of those reasons Kicker has. And it's the only thing I have. I know I tend to plank Kicker innocently, but well, I don't have any other ideas and time is running.
 
M.P. schrieb:
Somehow I don't like the idea of planking one for writing a post that would be totally normal in any German mutiny. And then there's the early interst for the couple, plus you voted for Florentina. 3 arguments which may not be really convincing but that's the best I have.
I have no good feeling about this post, that was directly after Am's complain. And I voted for Flo as a chief mate, where she already have experience- a captain must maintain a bit different task. I am a bit surprised you suddenly plank me after you somehow defended me today %) but if you mean- this is my explanation.
 
Second I found Lexi alittle wierd, as her descission for Mailin and Margaret was pretty fast and without any reasoning. Personally I do not really see the big difference in Mailin Margaret and for example Nam, so its kinda suprising that she was not even considering that. Sounded alittle like "Wanna make a 1-1 vote fast" Lexi also got only one vote for her, which seems wierd to me, considering that a medium skilled experienced player (Flo) was the choice of the majority.
dieLexi:
I think its al little bit fishy, that she decided her vote so quikly. I mean, of course Margaret and Mailin are great players, but why not Nam or Seme? I think they are as good as Margaret and Mailin.
If we had more functions to vote for, I could have been able to vote for all the good players round here. But there are only two and so I have to choose.
As some people stated before: There's a lot of good, experienced people here. I just can't go for all of them. There are only minor differences if anything. I just felt like going with Mailin and Margaret.
 
It sounds somehow like an excuse, after Am wrote above that it was mean and she wanted to play. Ok, it is just one phrase, but I somehow don't like it. The first plank, yes. But this choice of Flo as a captain doesn't somehow make it better, so I stay here.
And I even thought that argument would come... :rolleyes:

You could find planks for the next three days if you'd take all the posts after the first night's victim as a reason.

I have nothing against it to be planked (okay - yes I have!), but with a better reason please, ok? %)
 
First: Nope. You said, that it could be, that Galdra isn't confusing anymore. And you wrote, that I am sometimes confusing (not exactly these words, but it's the sense of it). But you just don't know if Galdra will be this time confusing or if I'll be confusing this round. So at the end, it is the same.
Really? But then you can´t sort somebody out just because he is confusing you too. You also can´t know if he/she will be in this round confusing too.

Second: But you wrote, that some people find her dangerous and some don't. And when I am sure, that I really don't want to choose a dangerous player, then I really wouldn't choose somebody, where at least half of the people are saying, that she is dangerous. I'd choose somebody where I can be sure, that she really isn't dangerous.
Maybe in this round she won`t be dangerous, I dont know. :D No, it´s just that I think that she is not as dangerous as Mailin for example and for me she was the best choice for officer.

Edit: I find no reason to plank somebody, but I think it will be Kicker. I have a bad feeling about him. :rolleyes:
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
I plank M.P, because I think he is more suspicious than dieLexi.

@dieLexi: I think it is suspicious that you not even mentioned them.
 
Ewry, you've got one minute left.
 
Guys, you CAN'T be serious!

ewry [2]: Kicker, Lexi
natti [2]: Nam, Margaret
Lexi [2]: Galdra, Seme
Seme [2]: Mailin [x2]
MP [2]: Mizuki, Flo
Kicker [2]: natti, ewry
Margaret [1]: MP

Second election between ewry, natti, Lexi, Seme, MP and Kicker until 19:45.
 
I forgot: please write your vote directly into the subject of your PMs, please.
 
What the... :lol:

I stay with MP.
 
:lol: I've never seen something like this.

I'm surely not going to vote for lexi, natti or ewry. So Kicker and Seme are left... uhm, will go for Seme and hope that this will turn out to be the right decision.

Edit:
@Seme
No, I don't have a real reason for this, I was only excluding all the other options.
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
I have no idea what I should think atm about that Natti and Ewry team up again and both vote against Kicker %)

Edit: Any reason for this M.P?

Edit: Sended in for M.P now, as from the 6 to vote I rather want to take another look at Kicker/Ewry, and obviously I do not plank myself. So there is Lexi Natti and M.P left, though I must say that Lexis answer convinced me for the moment to not plank her (was also thinking to change the first plank for a moment) See this as revenge or w/e but excluding all the people who are suspious and then planking me for 0 reason is just weird.
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
I simply hate you all.

MP [3]: Mizuki, Flo, Seme
Seme [3]: Mailin [x2], MP
Kicker [2]: natti, ewry
Natti [2]: Margaret, Nam
Lexi [1]: Galdra
Ewry [1]: Kicker

Third election between Seme and MP until 20:00.

And please WRITE THE NAME INTO THE SUBJECT OF YOUR PM!
 
Still MP, and my bad feeling concerning him just won't get better :naja:
 
No, I don't have a real reason for this, I was only excluding all the other options.

Are there at least some reasons why you're excluding the others?

My feeling with MP is not that bad, but I think it's worse than my feeling with Seme. So I'll probably take him this time, as I don't like his 'I will not vote for Y, so I vote for X - fullstop'.
 
Are there at least some reasons why you're excluding the others?

Lexi because she was one of the ones I wanted for the captain, you for not being suspisious at all and ewry for being suspected because of reasons I could understand but they weren't convincing enough. And then, when it was about to decide between Kicker and Seme, I don't know. I just followed my feelings.

Don't know. You will not achive anything if you plank me and as for Seme I'm still unsure but I don't have any other options. Do whatever you want.
 
Sorry, but no story, as I didn't know who's is going to be and there were too many possibilities.

MP [8]: Mizuki, Seme, Galdra, Margaret, natti, ewry, Nam, Flo
Seme [4]: MP, Mailin [x2], Kicker

MP will be locked into the warehouse. He's a normal officer. Mailin will be locked away too, because she's in love with him. Mailin is a lackey.

It's night, so be quiet.
 
Oh wow, I didn't expect a first plank like this :Oo:

Being a part of the sailors, I suggest natti or Nam for the next chief mate.

As for the mutineers, I think Galdra, Mizuki, Margaret and Florentina belong to them, but that'll be only a guess.

Good luck to the sailors :)
 
After cleverly disposing of the lovers, the lackeys were once more on the lookout for a victim. They caught sight of a lone person walking through Baker Street near the wine cellar. It was Sherlock Holmes [Mizuki]*, who, after determining the role of one unsuspecting person, tried to find his love.
"How convenient", one lackey said. "Let's just put him to the other one."
Holmes had just taken out a knife to pick the lock of the wine cellar when someone behind him said: “Let me help you with that.”
Holmes said "Oh, thank you" and turned around, not trusting that the person behind him was really nice and fully planning to hit him right into his or her face.
But to his misfortune, the lackey hadn't come alone. While the first lackey opened the door, the other two tackled Holmes and shoved him into the cellar.
Irene turned around to catch a stumbling Holmes in her arms. Holmes found himself right where he wanted to be: at her chest.
"Wine?" Irene asked, while seductively pulling of one of her silk gloves.

*Priest

Dates for tomorrow:

6:30 vote for man in charge
7:30 plank and afterwards meeting of the mutineers

You may talk.
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
Oh damn. Damn... :polter: Brilliant.

At least is Holmes again with Irene united...

Anyway, the priest is very bad now. Let's at last look what she could find out.

And this was the craziest plank I have ever seen :ohoh: Ok, at last M.P. was only a sailor and took Mailin with him... who was elected our our Man in Charge... interesting. One very good mutineer is found. Well, I will look tomorrow what can be concluded of all this what happened, after my headache is gone %)

Edit:
Naemi schrieb:
I think Mizuki might have questioned Mailin first, so I just expect just one helpful hint. But wait and see.
Why do you actually think so? (I hope it's not the case.)
 
Oh no, that’s not good. I mean lucky for us one of the Mutineers is gone, but the priest? I really hope she got at least one Mutineer and did not waste one night on Mailin.
 
@dieLexi: I think it is suspicious that you not even mentioned them.
I did. I said, there are several players that are as skilled and experienced as Mailin and Margaret. Oh, come on... I am suspicious for not writing out the names although everyone already knows who I am talking about? :Oo:

As I won't be here tomorrow I have to send in my plank and vote now. Unfortunately I don't have the time to wait for a hint by Mizuki. Therefore I will repeat my todays plank: ewry. Same reason, there was not enough time passing by to find something or someone else.

And I will vote for Margaret. I am still convinced she is really skilled and has a great ability of finding mutineers and so far she is not suspicious to me.


And boy, what a weird plank today! :eek:
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
And I already had my "goodbye" post prepared, telling that I think that Mailin is prolly not a muntineer as I doubt she would plank me without a proper reason and make herself that suspious on purpose %) But well.. its Mailin.

Death of the priest hurts us obviously but with Mailin one of the experienced mutineers is gone for sure, trying to analyze her moves is prolly useless but I maybe give it a shot tomorrow after my examn if I feel in the mood.

So we had sailors in the end to be voted for, so I would imagine that people would have spreaded more but only Kicker did in the end. I am not sure what to think of this atm. I still would need some time to sort this things in my head, I guess. I also would like to take another look at Lexi as now that one of her favourites turned out to be a mutineer it might be worth a 2nd look.
 
Oh, priest is bad. :argh: With luck Mizuki has found two mutineers or at least one, that would be really great. So waiting for her post. :)

Tomorrow I will be at home at about five o´clock, so before that I am not able to write here.

Well, we need an new officer. Maybe I am going to vote for natti again, because at the moment there is nothing to be said against it. Otherwise there will be time tomorrow to look for another candidate I think.

The thing wasn't if it is clever to vote for people who can be confusing - The point was, what's the difference between Galdra and me in this case? Do you get what I mean? %)
Mhm, I get what you mean. But nobody get what I mean. :D You focus all on this "confusing", maybe I should leave it out. Because in the end it was not important for me if she was/is/can be whatever confusing, but rather if she improved herself, so she may be a candidate.
 
You're thinking about a new first mate without waiting what Mizuki has to tell us? As for me, if she questioned a sailor, I'll elect him or her.
Yes, I´m not sure if will be punctual. This is a kind of precautionary choice. Until now Mizuki has written nothing yet. But if she questioned a sailor and I read it, I will choose the sailor of course. So this is not my fixed choice. That´s why I wrote
Otherwise there will be time tomorrow to look for another candidate I think.

:up: :D
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
Ok, I have a problem. I must go away about 13 and am not sure if I can be back before the election and the plank, I just hope I manage it. If Mizuki's post is not here until this point, I have to choose blind. I would elect myself as a first mate- yes it's not ideal today, but it's the only sure way then; with a bit luck I may have been questioned too. But not sure about the plank...

Just a bit of thoughts now. Looking at the elections, what we have:

Boss [Captain]:
Margaret [1] (Lexi)
Naemi [3] (Seme, Margaret, Mizuki)
Florentina [4] (Mailin, ewry, Kicker, natti)
Lexi [1] (M.P.)
Seme [2] (Naemi, Florentina)
Galdranorn [1] (Galdranorn)

Man in Charge [First mate]:
Mailin [2] (Lexi, Mailin)
Natti [2] (ewry, natti)

Seme [1] (Seme)
M.P. [1] (M.P.)
Kicker [1] (Kicker)
Naemi [1] (Naemi)
Florentina [3] (Margaret, Galdranorn, Florentina)
Mizuki [1] Mizuki

natti: [4] Mizuki, natti, Galdranorn, ewry
Mailin: [7] Mailin, Seme, Lexi, Kicker, Florentina, Margaret, M.P

The plank:
ewry [2]: Kicker, Lexi
natti [2]: Nam, Margaret
Lexi [2]: Galdra, Seme
Seme [2]: Mailin [x2]
MP [2]: Mizuki, Flo
Kicker [2]: natti, ewry
Margaret [1]: MP

then

MP [3]: Mizuki, Flo, Seme
Seme [3]: Mailin [x2], MP
Kicker [2]: natti, ewry
Natti [2]: Margaret, Nam
Lexi [1]: Galdra
Ewry [1]: Kicker


and finally

MP [8]: Mizuki, Seme, Galdra, Margaret, natti, ewry, Nam, Flo
Seme [4]: MP, Mailin [x2], Kicker

Ok, what is to see, Mailin had chosen herself and Flo as a captain. She had this idea that the other players deserve a chance. (I still think a captain need a good feeling not only for mutineers but also for special part- specially the priest usually gives hints before the duel... So I somehow don't like this idea, although still not sure what it could mean from her about Flo.)

Mailin was chosen by (herself and) Lexi. (And then she had more voices then natti.)

She also planked Seme, and nobody else did in the first turn. In the second only M.P., altough I suppose it was because of the couple, going together with Mailin. And this is somehow interesting, because there seems not to be a great desire to plank Seme (even in the end only Kicker. Who said not being lucky with both and M.P. seems more to be a sailor. At this point- why this thought?)

M.P. was planked by Mizuki (innocent) and Flo, later by Seme...

The plank is simple crazy. Well at last one sailor was in, but the spread is remarkable. And it's very difficult to read something out...

And I realise I have only little time because I still have to prepare :polter: Well I will try to read the reasons and posts about the plank in the remaining time, and I still hope Mizuki will give a hint in the right time.
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
Ok sorry, but I can't wait more.

I hope I will return before the plank, and can read then what happened, but now I have to leave and to send my choice to the might. I will elect myself as the first mate as mentioned, and my temporary plank will be Kicker. Yes I didn't completely forgot my small thought about natti, but it was a first plank too, and I somehow don't trust Kicker here now, after him being so focussed of ewry after Mailin told about her and his assumption that M.P. was a sailor (it may be subjective but at this point I didn't find M.P. looking more innocent than Seme %)) Anyway I really hope I will be back in time and then look.

Edit: Naemi: sadly it's still a foreign language and I have to write my thoughts in the most shortly (and maybe not ideal) way :D
 
Okay... (Wow, it is really much more difficult to start posting when you have to write everything in English... You could get the feeling that the german mutinies are totally easy :Oo:)

Okay, First I'd like to tell you why I chose Seme and not M.P. for the 3rd plank election. I really hadn't get what was wrong about M.P. I read something like "He defends Margaret!!!!" and then many people planked him and I really didn't understand that. Seme also wasn't like a mutineer to me (As I said: I was really not satisfied with that result) - She was neutral. And I know why, but in this moment, M.P. was rather a sailor than a mutineer (maybe just because I didn't get why so many people wanted to plank him) so I chose Seme and not him.

To the Point with Mailin: I would agree with Naemi here. I don't think that her tactic to choose a less experienced player really nothing tells us about Florentinas role. Seriously - It is Mailin. And when you got Mailin, you never can be sure what she wanted to purpose with it. I could even imagine that this was a kind of tactic with it she wanted to confuse us - I don't know what Florentina is - but I don't think that it makes that much sense to try to read something out in Mailins postings.

Okay, I'd like to say something about some players here... First is ewry. Believe me, I'm really not that sure about her as some people think I am - But for a first day, this have been enough reasons to plank somebody (I really had much worse reasons to plank somebody on the first day in other mutinies) and that was the way I did it. Okay, what do I think about ewry now... Last Night she finally brought me a understandable reason why she would choose Galdra but not me, even although it sounded as she said the same things to both. The reason, that she thinks that Galdra improved herself and I didn't, is... okay. Not really convincing, but okay. (But I feel bullied :zitter:)
But there is still the thing with her choice for Natti left. Okay - I understand that she didn't say that she would not want to choose a player which is dangerous (instead of experienced - I really hadn't get the difference, but now I think I get what she means.) Okay. In one posting, Ewry said that some people think that Natti is dangerous and some don't. And at this point I don't understand really why I choose somebody where at least a few people are saying, that she is dangerous, when I actually told twice that I'm not going to choose a dangerous player? Would it not make more sense to choose somebody where I can be sure, that he/she can't getting that much dangerous?

Oh, Ewry... What should I do with you? I'd take a close look at her the next days but I don't think that I'm going to plank her today.

And then there is Natti... If Ewry would be a mutineer, she would get very suspicious. But just if - And as long I don't know which role ewry has got, I can't "attack" natti from this point. But I found here a little bit strange before the plank (yes, and here will come ewry again...), first thing was this quote:
Natti schrieb:
Kicker is really fast in thinking ewry is suspicious. I don't like that, but I think that's one of Kicker's main problems as sailor - he is too fast in thinking :D So I'm not sure whether I'll plank him.
She says that she isn't sure if she'll plank me (later, she did it.) - But in the same sentence she also say that I am playing with my main problem as a sailor. I don't get why I was that suspicious here now, when she itself says that I play like me as a sailor.
I'd like to hear again from Natti, why she planked me :)

Okay and now call me obsessed - but I don't like it which two people planked me. Ewry and Natti. As I said - I don't understand why ewry chose Natti as her choice and now exactly this two are the people who planked me. Especially Ewry's plank for me sounds to me like a Revenge Plank. I would not say now: "THEY ARE MUTINEES!!!", but I just wanted to add that, because I find it at least a bit strange, although I have no clue what would be the sense of this action - So I also would not be that surprised if this means nothing.

Okay, and at the end there is Lexi left. As many people said before - It is a bit strange how she chose her candidates for the election. Very directly and the reason is a bit strange.
Lexi schrieb:
Of course there are several other players that are as skilled, experienced... as Mailin and Margaret. Nevertheless I hope they might be slightly better in finding mutineers.
I don't find the reason here why calculated these two are the two people which would do their jobs best. She itselfs says, that there are several other players which got the same skills like them - Why did she didn't choose one of them? Just a "I hope that..." is not really a good reason.
Somebody (I don't remember who it was) already said it: It sounds a bit like 1 Sailor and 1 Mutiny. And as we know now, Mailin was a mutineer. Same as above: I would not scream "Mutineeer!!!", but I would take a close look at Lexi.

By the way - I don't get the idea of Margaret to choose herself as the officer, when she isn't sure if she can be here tonight - An Officer who can't change its choice when something important happens isn't really useful imo.
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
I hope Mizuki will give us some advices before the vote ends (if not, it would be great if the force writes a priest-like comment :D) because I have no idea which person I should chose
 
Me too and I start feeling a bit uneasy by now. I don't know why this takes so long, maybe Mizuki doesn't know how to write the post or she sent it to the might who wasn't online since yesterday evening 9 pm.
I'd also be very delighted if the might could update the first post :)

Otherwise if there won't be a post before the votings, I'll choose myself again because there's nobody here I'm trusting enough to want to have him or her as first mate.

Maybe Mizuki wasn't at home yesterday (and she didn't watch what happened here) and today she is at work? Then we could just hope, that she doesn't work until 7pm or something like that...
 
Maybe Mizuki wasn't at home yesterday (and she didn't watch what happened here) and today she is at work? Then we could just hope, that she doesn't work until 7pm or something like that...

I really doubt that, because she elected herself as officer. So I think Nam's theory is more likely.

@Lexi: It wasn't clear for me. I didn't know you meant Nam and Seme. I mean natti for examples is a pretty good player too and some players including me think that she belongs in the same category as Nam, Seme, Mailin and Margaret. Besides that, you never gave any satisfying explanation why you didn't choose one of them.

I'm really looking forward to Mizukis post, which will contain at least one role of an player. So 'I am going to wait for that and then I'll post my choice for the first mate.Unless there is no post until 6:30.
 
While I am still waiting for the post from Mizuki, I made up some thoughts.

Atm with the current situation I could imagine another experienced player under the mutineers as Mizuki is not really a weak priest so therefor I would find a team alittle unfair with only Mailin + 3 middlefield mutineers.

So this leaves me with Nam, Margaret and Natti. We had a run-off for the captains spot between Mailin and Natti, where Mailin won with a big headstart. The question I see here is now, if it was a vote between 2 mutineers or sailor and mutineer here. I could imagine (if natti is a sailor) that the majority of mutineers voted for a strong Mailin as the Chiefs Mate spot is generally awsome for the mutineers. But well atm I am far to unsure with those 3 people anyway (Nam/Natti/Margaret) so unlike the priest shows me that one of them is sailor I will not vote for them as Chief Mate.

I am not sure what I should think of the Margaret and Nam planking Natti action either atm. As far i remember Nams play, she loves to "mate" up with sailors if she mutineers but this is all alittle vage atm. Regarding Nam I would love to believe that Mizuki questioned her and voted for her cause of that for the captains spot, as I usually got a bad feeling with Nam the last few games (prolly cause I fear her the most :D) but I fear that it might have been Mailin, who got questioned.

The thing is that I still hope that we had a mutineer under the 6 planked people, as otherwise it would be really really wierd to only have sailors there. So M.P was a sailor, I am a sailor, which leaves Natti, Kicker, Lexi and Ewry.

Personally I would like to put my mainfocus on those as I see chances high there to find a mutineer. From those there is the connection between Kicker, Natti and Ewry over the Kicker plank from them, and the plank from Kicker vs Ewry. Atm I see Kicker alittle "green" as the vote for me instead of M.P only made him stand out which is not really the way to go for a mutineer, specially as M.P showed alot of things which looked wierd (in my view atleast) Could be though that he already knew that Mailin will die with M.P but atm I rather see him as sailor.

I already mentioned regarding Natti, that I could imagine that it was a run-off between sailor and mutineer there between her and Mailin, as most people picked Mailin over her. So atm I would love to tend alittle to sailor. Also the argument Nam brought up, that it would be really silly to jump on the bandwagon with voting for Flo, which Mailin started, points alittle into the sailor direction.

Ok so we got my two favourite players left again, as atm I find both (still/again) suspect, and I will have another closer look on them later once again.
 

Zur Zeit aktive Besucher

Zurück
Oben Unten